교재 바로가기 
스터디 실행윤리적 딜레마: 누구를 믿어야 할까?
Ethical dilemma: Who should you believe?
스터디 실행
Preview
If your spouse is accused of murder but claims innocence, should you believe them? According to evidentialism, we should only believe what evidence supports—regardless of personal ties. But pragmatism argues that practical and emotional consequences—like harming trust in a relationship—can justify belief even without strong evidence. Some philosophers even say we have a moral duty to believe in loved ones during difficult times. Yet others question whether we can truly choose what to believe when the facts suggest otherwise.
를 눌러보세요!a statement that someone did something wrong or illegal
The teacher made an accusation that John had cheated on the test.based on reason and logic, not emotions
She made a rational decision instead of acting out of anger.a strong feeling for or against something, making it hard to be fair
News channels should not show bias when reporting stories.morally wrong; not following right or fair behavior
It is unethical to lie about your qualifications on a job application.very important
The last minute of the game was crucial for the team’s victory.in a way that shows great need or desire
He desperately needed money to pay his rent.를 눌러보세요!to be surprising or unexpected
The news came as a shock to everyone in the office.to consider something when making a decision
We should take into account the weather before planning the picnic.to be in danger of something happening
He ran the risk of losing his job by arguing with his boss.를 눌러보세요!1. If you were in the situation from the video, would you believe your spouse or the evidence? Why?
여러분이 동영상 속 상황에 처했다면 배우자나 증거를 믿으시겠습니까? 왜 그럴까요?
2. In this case, what kind of additional evidence would you need to be sure of the truth?
이 경우 진실을 확인하기 위해 어떤 종류의 추가 증거가 필요하나요?
3. Imagine a close friend is accused of a serious crime, but they say they are innocent. Would you trust them no matter what?
친한 친구가 심각한 범죄 혐의로 기소되었지만 무죄라고 주장한다고 상상해 보세요. 무슨 일이 있어도 그 친구를 믿으시겠습니까?
4. Have you ever been in a situation where you didn’t know who to believe? What happened?
누구를 믿어야 할지 모르는 상황에 처한 적이 있나요? 어떤 일이 있었나요?
5. Do you think believing someone without evidence is irrational or loyal?
증거 없이 누군가를 믿는 것이 비합리적이거나 충성스럽다고 생각하시나요?
6. Some philosophers believe we have a moral responsibility to believe only what the evidence supports. Do you agree?
일부 철학자들은 우리에게 증거가 뒷받침하는 것만 믿어야 할 도덕적 책임이 있다고 생각합니다. 동의하시나요?
7. If someone desperately wants to believe something, do you think they can force themselves to believe it?
누군가가 필사적으로 무언가를 믿고 싶어 한다면 억지로 믿게 할 수 있을까요?
8. Have you ever seen a false accusation case in the news? What happened?
뉴스에서 허위 고발 사건을 본 적이 있나요? 무슨 일이 있었나요?
9. Do you trust the legal system in your country? Why or why not?
거주하고 있는 국가의 법률 시스템을 신뢰하시나요? 왜 또는 왜 그렇지 않나요?
10. What do you think hurts more: Being accused of something you didn’t do, or Not being believed by someone you love?
무엇이 더 아프다고 생각하시나요? 자신이 하지 않은 일로 비난을 받는 것과 사랑하는 사람이 믿어주지 않는 것 중 어떤 것이 더 아프다고 생각하시나요?
스터디a statement that someone did something wrong or illegal
The teacher made an accusation that John had cheated on the test.교정 결과
based on reason and logic, not emotions
She made a rational decision instead of acting out of anger.교정 결과
a strong feeling for or against something, making it hard to be fair
News channels should not show bias when reporting stories.교정 결과
morally wrong; not following right or fair behavior
It is unethical to lie about your qualifications on a job application.교정 결과
very important
The last minute of the game was crucial for the team’s victory.교정 결과
in a way that shows great need or desire
He desperately needed money to pay his rent.교정 결과
to be surprising or unexpected
The news came as a shock to everyone in the office.교정 결과
to consider something when making a decision
We should take into account the weather before planning the picnic.교정 결과
to be in danger of something happening
He ran the risk of losing his job by arguing with his boss.교정 결과
If you were in the situation from the video, would you believe your spouse or the evidence? Why?
여러분이 동영상 속 상황에 처했다면 배우자나 증거를 믿으시겠습니까? 왜 그럴까요?
교정 결과
In this case, what kind of additional evidence would you need to be sure of the truth?
이 경우 진실을 확인하기 위해 어떤 종류의 추가 증거가 필요하나요?
교정 결과
Imagine a close friend is accused of a serious crime, but they say they are innocent. Would you trust them no matter what?
친한 친구가 심각한 범죄 혐의로 기소되었지만 무죄라고 주장한다고 상상해 보세요. 무슨 일이 있어도 그 친구를 믿으시겠습니까?
교정 결과
Have you ever been in a situation where you didn’t know who to believe? What happened?
누구를 믿어야 할지 모르는 상황에 처한 적이 있나요? 어떤 일이 있었나요?
교정 결과
Do you think believing someone without evidence is irrational or loyal?
증거 없이 누군가를 믿는 것이 비합리적이거나 충성스럽다고 생각하시나요?
교정 결과
Some philosophers believe we have a moral responsibility to believe only what the evidence supports. Do you agree?
일부 철학자들은 우리에게 증거가 뒷받침하는 것만 믿어야 할 도덕적 책임이 있다고 생각합니다. 동의하시나요?
교정 결과
If someone desperately wants to believe something, do you think they can force themselves to believe it?
누군가가 필사적으로 무언가를 믿고 싶어 한다면 억지로 믿게 할 수 있을까요?
교정 결과
Have you ever seen a false accusation case in the news? What happened?
뉴스에서 허위 고발 사건을 본 적이 있나요? 무슨 일이 있었나요?
교정 결과
Do you trust the legal system in your country? Why or why not?
거주하고 있는 국가의 법률 시스템을 신뢰하시나요? 왜 또는 왜 그렇지 않나요?
교정 결과
What do you think hurts more: Being accused of something you didn’t do, or Not being believed by someone you love?
무엇이 더 아프다고 생각하시나요? 자신이 하지 않은 일로 비난을 받는 것과 사랑하는 사람이 믿어주지 않는 것 중 어떤 것이 더 아프다고 생각하시나요?
교정 결과
꼭 영어로 작성하지 않아도 되어요!
아래 세 가지 방식 모두 가능해요.
· I feel lucky because I had a really nice dream!
· I feel 행운 because I had 정말 좋은 꿈!
· 정말 좋은 꿈을 꿔서 오늘은 운이 좋을 것 같아!